BACK TO MENU

Why is the response to bird flu so muted?

Plus, just how many cows have H5N1, two vaccines could be ready within weeks, and missing data makes this hard to track.

May 3, 2024

Bird Flu News

  • Two bird flu vaccines could be available within weeks, if needed, officials say. (NBC)
  • Missing data is making it hard to track bird flu virus changes. (STAT)
  • The USDA says 30 samples of ground beef tested negative for the bird flu virus. (CBS)
  • Dairy products, including sour cream and cottage cheese, tested negative for live H5N1 virus after initially testing positive for viral fragments. (CIDRAP)
  • While no cases of H5N1 have yet been found in Canadian cows, scientists warn that Canada’s lack of a national surveillance program leaves them ‘way behind the virus’. (CBC)
  • The U.S. is likely missing human cases of bird flu. (NPR)

Health News:

  • Norovirus broke out on two cruises this month, infecting 69 and 114 people, respectively. (WTSP)
  • The USDA told producers to reduce salmonella in certain frozen chicken products to lower the chances of food poisoning. (Washington Post)
  • The CDC warned of an E. coli O157:H7 outbreak linked to organic bulk walnuts sold at natural foods stores and co-ops in 19 states. (CDC)
  • The WHO recently overturned long-time guidance on how airborne diseases spread, but it’s unclear if the CDC will match their new guidelines. (Yahoo)
  • Women are now advised to get annual mammograms starting at 40, the US Preventive Services task force announced this week. (CNN)
  • 1 person has died, and 9 are hospitalized in a TB outbreak in Long Beach, CA. (CBS)
  • 16,000+ pounds of ground beef from Cargill Meat Solutions were recalled due to E. coli O157:H7 contamination, the USDA announced Wednesday. (FSIS)
  • North Idaho has a whooping cough outbreak, with 19 cases so far this year, compared to just 9 in all of last year. (Idaho Statesman)
  • A fun one - a wild orangutan was observed using a medicinal plant to treat and cover his own wound. (Axios)

Mental Health & Substance Use News:

  • May is National Mental Health Awareness Month, as declared by President Biden. (White House)
  • Mental health crisis centers are offering care that busy ERs can’t. (STAT)
  • 3 in 4 Americans feel that mental health takes a back seat to physical health. (ABC)

If you or someone you know may be considering suicide or need help, call 988 or message the Crisis Text Line by texting HOME to 741741.


Best Questions:

Just how widespread is bird flu in cows? 

It’s very hard to say because until just this week, any testing for H5N1 in cows was voluntary, so the data are very limited. We know for sure that 36 herds in nine states have tested positive, but the real numbers may be much higher. One way we can get a better sense for this is to test milk. The FDA tested nearly 300 grocery store samples from 38 states and found fragments of the virus in one out of every five. Grocery milk combines milk from multiple individual cows, so it doesn’t necessarily translate directly to 20% of all cows being infected, but it does indicate that there is much wider spread than we initially realized. Between those numbers, data from genetic sequencing, and the accounts of cattle farmers on the ground in Texas, where the first confirmed cases were found in cows, this may have started spreading between cows back in December 2023. As of right now, there’s no evidence of the virus in beef cattle, but again, there’s very limited testing at this stage. 

Sources: STAT, FDA, Dr. A. Rasmussen, Anderson et. al. BioRxiv

Why is the public health response to H5N1 in cows so muted? 

Despite the growing concerns about the possibility of a jump to humans, only about 25 people have been tested for H5N1 bird flu in the U.S. as of Wednesday. There are a lot of factors at play in this one. First, the dairy and cattle industries make up hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue. They won’t just cull sick herds like the poultry industry does, in part because cows recover in a few weeks and are more valuable individually than chickens, for example. Both the USDA and CDC have said that farmers have often refused to cooperate with their investigations, likely because none want to bear the risk of going public. There’s an added layer of complication because the human workers who are most at risk for a spillover event are often undocumented, a population who understandably tend to distrust government officials. On top of all that, there’s some jurisdictional jockeying; the CDC said recently that they haven't been officially invited in as a partner by any of the nine states with positive dairy herds, though they’re in regular contact. It’s a sticky situation and one that is starting to really worry public health officials who want to see more testing of animals and humans working on farms. 

Sources: STAT, NBC, NPR

If hundreds of humans have been infected with bird flu over the years, why is this dairy worker in TX any different?

Almost 900 people have been infected with H5N1 bird flu virus since 2003 when it was first identified in Southeast Asia. In all 900 of these prior cases, the sick person had contact with sick or dead birds. But the farm worker in Texas who tested positive for H5N1 is different because he only had contact with sick cows. A new study looked at the genetic material of the viral sample and found that it had mammalian mutations, meaning it may be the first case we know of that went from a bird to another mammal (a cow) to a human. Unfortunately, the person in Texas did not consent to give any blood samples, and the owner of the farm appears to have refused to allow health officials to investigate further, so the information we can glean is limited. The good news is that the genetics of the viral sample taken from the infected human are still a good match for our human H5N1 vaccines. 

Sources: STAT, NEJM

Best Read:

Bird Flu Is Bad for Poultry and Dairy Cows. It’s Not a Dire Threat for Most of Us — Yet. - KFF Health News